Victor Davis Hanson: 'The Democratic Party Has Collapsed'

Opinion:

Victor Davis Hanson's recent assertions regarding the so-called "collapse" of the Democratic Party, articulated during his appearance on Mark Levin's FOX News show, merit a closer examination through a historical and socio-political lens. While he posits that the Democrats' current trajectory reflects a fundamental weakness, such a view is indicative of a broader narrative often employed by conservative commentators seeking to delegitimize progressive movements. The claim that the party is floundering overlooks the resilience of contemporary grassroots movements and the historical context in which the Democratic Party has navigated various crises.

To understand the historical arc of the Democratic Party's evolution, one must consider its foundational principles and the numerous transformations it has undergone since its inception in the early 19th century. The party has often been a site of internal conflict, balancing the interests of diverse factions—from labor unions to civil rights advocates. This internal strife has frequently been weaponized by opponents who claim that disunity equates to failure. Yet, such claims often ignore the party’s historical ability to adapt and respond to the evolving needs of its constituents. For instance, the civil rights movement of the 1960s saw the Democratic Party embrace progressive reforms that ultimately led to its realignment and the alienation of Southern conservative voters. This historical precedent suggests that the party's current struggles may be less about collapse and more about transformation.

Hanson's assertion that Democrats are "on the wrong side of major issues" reflects a conservative framing that dismisses progressive priorities, such as climate action, healthcare reform, and social justice, as misguided. However, polling data consistently demonstrates that a significant portion of the American electorate supports these issues. For instance, a 2021 Gallup poll found that a majority of Americans believe in the necessity of addressing climate change, reflecting a desire for action that transcends partisan divides. This gap between voter sentiment and the narratives pushed by conservative commentators underscores a critical disconnect that progressives can leverage in political discourse. By illustrating that their values resonate with the electorate, progressives can help dismantle the narrative of Democratic failure.

Hanson’s comments regarding Trump's strategy to target the "sources of power" for the left warrant scrutiny. This framing suggests a tactical approach to dismantling progressive coalitions through a culture war that distracts from substantive policy discussions. Historically, such strategies have been employed to mobilize conservative bases by creating an "us vs. them" dichotomy that vilifies progressive movements. The targeting of institutions such as public education, the media, and various social services reflects an ongoing effort to undermine progressive achievements. A thoughtful response from the left should underscore the importance of defending these institutions, which are often the bedrock of democratic engagement and social equity.

In conclusion, while Hanson’s depiction of a "collapsed" Democratic Party may resonate within certain media circles, it is essential to recognize the resilience of progressive movements and the historical context in which these narratives are situated. The ongoing struggles for racial justice, environmental sustainability, and economic equality are far from signs of weakness; they are indicative of a vibrant and evolving political landscape that continues to challenge the status quo. By reframing the conversation around these issues, progressives can not only counter the narratives of collapse but also galvanize support for a more inclusive and equitable society. This ongoing dialogue is crucial as we move toward the 2024 election and beyond, reminding us that the fight for justice and progress is far from over.

Action:

The assertion by Victor Davis Hanson that “the Democratic Party has collapsed” reflects a broader narrative prevalent in certain conservative circles, especially as we approach the 2024 election. This perspective, which positions the Democratic Party as being in a state of disarray, requires a nuanced examination, particularly in light of historical precedents and the political landscape. While it is true that the Democratic Party faces significant challenges, it is crucial to analyze the roots of these issues and consider the possibilities for renewal and transformation within the party.

Historically, the Democratic Party has experienced periods of crisis and reinvention, from the Great Depression to the civil rights movement. Each time, it has had to navigate internal divisions and external pressures to emerge with a clearer message and stronger voter support. The current political climate, marked by polarization and extreme partisanship, presents unique challenges reminiscent of the party's past struggles. Rather than viewing these difficulties as a sign of collapse, it might be more productive to see them as an opportunity for re-evaluation and re-engagement with the electorate. The Democratic Party must confront its historical context and the evolving needs of its constituents to regain its footing.

In terms of action, Americans who align with progressive values can play a pivotal role in reshaping the Democratic Party’s trajectory. Grassroots movements have historically been the backbone of significant political change, and now is the time to mobilize around issues such as climate justice, healthcare for all, and workers’ rights. Engaging in local politics, advocating for candidates who prioritize progressive policies, and organizing community forums can help rejuvenate the party’s base. By empowering voices from marginalized communities and prioritizing their concerns, the party can cultivate a more inclusive platform that resonates with a broader electorate.

Moreover, the importance of education and awareness cannot be overstated as we navigate these complex political landscapes. Sharing knowledge about the Democratic Party’s historical achievements and the lessons learned from past setbacks can inspire a sense of continuity and purpose. Initiatives that focus on civic education, teaching the importance of participation in democracy, and encouraging dialogue on critical issues can bridge the gap often exploited by partisan narratives. When citizens are informed and engaged, they can challenge oversimplified views that suggest the party is in a state of collapse and instead highlight the ongoing efforts to build a more equitable society.

Finally, addressing the notion that Donald Trump is “going after the sources of power” held by the left requires a strategic counter-narrative that emphasizes the importance of shared values and collective action. While Trump’s tactics may seem combative, it is essential to frame a response that reinforces the integrity of democratic institutions and the rule of law. Engaging in discussions about the importance of accountability, transparency, and the preservation of democratic norms can counteract attempts to delegitimize the Democratic Party. By fostering an environment where constructive discourse is valued over divisive rhetoric, we can create a political culture that prioritizes the common good over partisan victories.

In conclusion, rather than succumbing to the narrative of collapse presented by figures like Hanson, we must embrace the challenges facing the Democratic Party as opportunities for growth and reform. By harnessing grassroots activism, promoting education, and fostering constructive dialogue, we can work collectively to strengthen our political institutions and advocate for policies that reflect our shared values. This approach not only counters the rhetoric of collapse but also lays the groundwork for a more resilient and inclusive political future.

To Do:

In response to the claims made by Victor Davis Hanson regarding the perceived collapse of the Democratic Party, it’s essential to mobilize and take action in order to strengthen progressive values and advocate for policies that resonate with a broad audience. Below is a detailed list of ideas and actionable steps that can be taken to counteract narratives that undermine progressive ideals and to actively engage with the political process:

### Personal Actions to Take

1. **Educate Yourself and Others** - Attend local political meetings or town halls to better understand the issues at hand. - Host discussion groups to talk about the importance of progressive policies and the implications of the upcoming elections.

2. **Engage with Local Representatives** - Write to your local representative expressing your concerns about the current political landscape and advocating for progressive policies. - Example contact: - **Your Representative’s Name** - **Office Address** (look up your local representative online). - **Email** (usually available on their official website).

3. **Support Grassroots Organizations** - Volunteer with or donate to organizations that promote progressive causes. Examples include: - **Sierra Club** (environmental advocacy) - **Planned Parenthood** (reproductive rights) - **MoveOn.org** (progressive political action)

4. **Petition for Change** - Start or sign petitions that address critical local and national issues. For example: - **Change.org** and **Care2** are platforms where you can find or create petitions on various issues. - Example petition: "Demand Congress Opposes Cuts to Social Programs" can be initiated on these platforms.

### Specific Actions to Take

1. **Write Letters to the Editor** - Express your views in local newspapers about the importance of progressive policies and countering negative narratives. Be sure to: - Mention specific issues you care about (e.g., healthcare, climate change). - Use your local paper's submission guidelines to get published.

2. **Contact Party Leadership** - Reach out to Democratic National Committee (DNC) leadership to express your thoughts on the party's direction. Example contacts include: - **DNC Chair: Jaime Harrison** - Email: [info@democrats.org](mailto:info@democrats.org) - Mailing Address: Democratic National Committee, 430 S. Capitol St. SE, Washington, DC 20003

3. **Involve Yourself in Local Elections** - Support local candidates who align with progressive values. Research candidates in your area and volunteer for their campaigns. - Example: Find local city council or school board candidates and offer your time for canvassing or fundraising.

4. **Participate in Advocacy Days** - Join organizations that host advocacy days where constituents meet with their representatives to discuss specific issues. - Check websites of organizations you support for upcoming events.

5. **Use Social Media Wisely** - Share information, articles, and personal insights on social media platforms to raise awareness about critical issues. Use hashtags to join broader conversations (#ProgressiveChange, #FightFor15).

6. **Organize or Join Community Events** - Participate in or organize rallies, marches, or community meetings focused on pressing issues like climate action, healthcare reform, or voting rights.

### What to Say

When communicating your thoughts or advocating for change, it’s important to articulate your views clearly:

- **Express Your Concerns**: “I believe that our party needs to focus on unifying around key issues like healthcare access and climate change to regain trust and support from voters.” - **Advocate for Action**: “I urge you to prioritize legislation that addresses income inequality and supports working families, as these are the core issues that resonate with constituents.” - **Call for Unity**: “It’s crucial for our party to present a clear and cohesive vision that addresses the needs of all Americans, rather than getting caught in reactive politics.”

By taking these actions, you can contribute to a stronger, more unified approach that emphasizes progressive values and addresses the challenges highlighted by critics.