Vigil mourns man killed on freeway after ICE enforcement at Monrovia Home Depot
whittierdailynews.com -- Friday, August 15, 2025, 11:27:24 PM Eastern Daylight Time
Categories: Presidential Campaigns, Political Protests & Rallies, Immigration Policy & Border Issues
To the more than 300 people gathered at the corner of Mountain East Evergreen avenues in Monrovia, the man who died after he ran onto the 210 Freeway in Monrovia and was hit by an SUV now has a name.
Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez was a 52-year-old from Guatemala. He lived in Arcadia, official said. The throng gathered Friday at the Monrovia Home Depot to mourn him and to call for an end to the Trump Administration's recent amped-up immigration enforcement.
Montoya Valdez's identity was confirmed by the Guatemalan consulate, said Pablo Alvarado, director of the National Day Laborer Organizing Network, who was at the Home Depot parking lot in Monrovia on Friday. Montoya Valdez is from Jutiapa, Guatemala, he said.
Alvarado said he believes the man has a cousin living in the area. An official with the consulate couldn't be reached for comment on Friday afternoon.
The California Highway Patrol is investigating how and why the man ended up on the freeway.
ICE agents were at the Home Depot in Monrovia that morning but Department of Homeland Security officials on Friday denied officers chased the man.
"This individual was not being pursued by any DHS law enforcement," according to a statement from the Department of Homeland Security. "We do not know their legal status. We were not aware of this incident or notified by California Highway Patrol until hours after operations in the area had concluded."
Also see: Man fleeing from ICE raid in Monrovia fatally struck on 210 Freeway
Even if authorities were not chasing Montoya Valdez, if masked men showed up, the instinct is to run, Alvarado said. "It's scary."
Everybody would run, not just day laborers, according to Alvarado.
"They say they want to protect public safety. Their own operations endanger public safety," Alvarado said.
The CHP received reports at 9:48 a.m. Thursday about a crash involving a Ford Expedition and a pedestrian blocking a traffic lane on the 210 Freeway, east of Myrtle Avenue, in Monrovia.
The man was running north across all eastbound lanes when he was struck by an SUV in the far left lane traveling about 50 to 60 mph, a CHP statement said.
Jeff Nunez, 51, of Brentwood, was driving the Expedition.
The pedestrian, who suffered major injuries, died at a hospital, CHP officials said.
The crash, including circumstances surrounding how and why the pedestrian was on the freeway, remains under investigation by the CHP's Baldwin Park Area.
As of Friday afternoon, the medical examiner's office had not yet publicly identified the pedestrian killed.
There were five men waiting for work at the Home Depot parking lot on Mountain Avenue shortly before noon on Friday. Two stood under a tree. One was sitting in a pickup truck and later approached by two other men.
The man in the pickup, who didn't want his name used in this report, said he has known the man who died yesterday as "Carlos" for two years. He was at the Home Depot on Thursday and saw Carlos, where agents tried to detain Carlos in the parking lot. He left and didn't know how Carlos got on the freeway.
One of the men standing under the tree also declined to give his name.
"Everybody (is) looking for work here," the man said. "(They) don't want to talk about this."
Duarte Mayor Cesar Andres Garcia said he spoke to Montoya Valdez's roommate, who said family was mobilizing to transfer Valdez's remains to Guatemala, where his daughters and a grandson live. Garcia said he and others were working to connect the family with the Guatemalan Consulate.
The incident sparked protests on Thursday at the scene of the ICE raid. Demonstrators voiced outrage over the death and called for an end to the continued immigration enforcement operations taking place in and around Los Angeles.
Garcia also issued a statement Thursday, adding that City of Hope staff turned immigration enforcement officers away at the Duarte campus the same day.
"The thought that someone looking for work and to provide for their family lost their life in this manner is heartbreaking," Garcia said.
Federal operations began in early June throughout the county, fueled by President Donald Trump's pledge to mass deport undocumented immigrants. But since then, armed, masked federal agents have descended on communities large and small in a dragnet that has frightened many residents in the region, and hit immigrant-dependent industries particularly hard.
The Trump administration has hailed the crackdown as a success, pointing to an array of arrests throughout the country of immigrations with serious criminal records.
The raids had been halted in July by a federal judge's order, upheld by an appeals court, that limited the kind of stops federal agents can make -- the kind based solely on apparent race or ethnicity; speaking Spanish or English with an accent; presence in a particular location like a bus stop, car wash, or agricultural site; or the type of work a person does.
The National Day Laborer Organizing Network, based in Pasadena, will hold the vigil at The Home Depot store at 6 p.m.
"The worker was fleeing an unannounced raid by immigration agents, the latest in an ongoing wave of violent, chaotic kidnappings and assaults that ICE and other agencies are waging at Home Depots and other locations across Southern California," according to a statement from the group.
On Thursday, state Sen. Sasha Renée Pérez, D-Pasadena, issued a statement decrying the raids and referenced the death, which was in her district.
"President Trump's terror campaign has taken another life," she said, while also offering her condolences to the man's family.
"There is such incredible fear in our immigrant communities, so much so that people will run into freeway traffic out of fear when all they want is a chance to support their family and seek the American Dream,"
Pérez called for an end to what she described as violent and sweeping.
"The Trump Administration is violating a federal court order by continuing to conduct deadly roving immigration raids within the area of the U.S. District Court's Central District of California that includes Los Angeles County," she stated. "These raids have been ruled to be illegal racial profiling by a federal judge and the Trump Administration has been ordered to comply with a temporary restraining order."
Pérez has been an advocate for comprehensive immigration law reform.
"How many more brown-skinned people have to die before the president will obey the law?" she asked. "There is a better way. Comprehensive immigration reform that both parties work on is the only solution. I renew my call to pursue this path and stop the terror."
Homeland Security officials have repeatedly defended the work of ICE agents, denying allegations that operations are carried out randomly.
"Every single one of our ICE and Border Patrol operations is built on information, on investigative work," Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Thursday during an appearance on Fox News when asked about a downtown Los Angeles raid conducted outside a building where Gov. Gavin Newsom was holding a news conference.
She said ICE agents conduct operations at specific locations "because of who they think could be in that area and what they have for information that shows there are illegal criminals there. Remember we're focusing on the worst of the worst."
"We extend our condolences for the individual and his family," said a statement from Monrovia City Manager Dylan Feik on Thursday. "We also express our appreciation to the Monrovia Police Department and its volunteers, Monrovia Fire & Rescue as well as the California Highway Patrol."
The CHP was continuing its investigation into the circumstances surrounding how and why the pedestrian ran onto the freeway, according to a CHP statement. Anyone with information about this incident is encouraged to contact Officer J. Rosas, during business hours, at .
Sign Our PetitionThe tragic death of Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez, a 52-year-old Guatemalan man who was struck by a vehicle while fleeing an ICE enforcement operation, embodies the urgent and often overlooked human costs of aggressive immigration policies. The vigil held in Monrovia, California, where over 300 people gathered to mourn and protest, highlights the intersection of state-sanctioned enforcement and the lived realities of immigrant communities. This incident is not merely a singular event; it reflects a broader historical pattern of immigration enforcement that often prioritizes punitive measures over human dignity and safety.
To understand the gravity of Montoya Valdez's death, we must consider the historical context of U.S. immigration policy. The ramping up of immigration enforcement, particularly during the Trump administration, is rooted in a long-standing tradition of criminalizing immigration. Policies that prioritize deportation and aggressive raids create environments of fear and desperation. As Pablo Alvarado from the National Day Laborer Organizing Network pointedly noted, the presence of ICE agents can incite a natural instinct to flee. This reaction is a survival mechanism cultivated amid a history of trauma and insecurity faced by many immigrants, particularly from countries like Guatemala, where violence and poverty are pervasive. The fact that Montoya Valdez ran onto a freeway in a panic underscores the urgency of addressing not just immigration policy, but the socio-economic conditions that compel individuals to cross borders in search of safety and opportunity.
Moreover, the assertion by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) that Montoya Valdez was not pursued adds another layer of disconnection between policy and reality. Regardless of the technicalities of whether he was being chased at that moment, the presence of ICE alone creates a climate of fear that can lead to tragic outcomes. Alvarado’s statement that “their own operations endanger public safety” serves as a crucial reminder that the actions of state agencies can have direct and devastating consequences on the lives of everyday people. Indeed, this incident raises critical questions about the effectiveness and morality of immigration enforcement as it stands, challenging the narrative that equates strict enforcement with public safety.
The local community's response demonstrates a collective reckoning with these realities. The gathering for Montoya Valdez was not just an act of mourning; it was a defiant stand against a system that often treats immigrants as expendable. It speaks to the solidarity that can emerge in the face of injustice, a reminder of the power of collective action in advocating for policy change. The voices of the mourners echo a growing call for comprehensive immigration reform that prioritizes the humanity of immigrants over punitive measures. Such reform must address the root causes of migration, including economic disparity and violence in home countries, rather than merely focusing on border enforcement.
Furthermore, this incident is emblematic of broader social struggles that intertwine with the fight for immigrant rights. The vigil and the community’s outcry should serve as a rallying point for discussions around social justice movements that advocate for a more humane and equitable approach to immigration. As we witness increasing polarization in political discourse, it is vital to center the narratives of those most affected by these policies and to challenge the misconceptions that often accompany discussions of immigration. By invoking the memory of individuals like Montoya Valdez, advocates can illuminate the urgent need for compassion and systemic change, ensuring that immigrant lives are valued and protected, rather than marginalized and endangered.
In conclusion, the death of Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez is a profound tragedy that highlights the dire consequences of aggressive immigration enforcement and the urgent need for reforms that respect the dignity and humanity of all individuals. As we engage in conversations about immigration policy, we must remember that behind statistics and political rhetoric lie real people with dreams, struggles, and the desire for safety. This incident is a call to action for communities across the country to unite and advocate for policies that prioritize justice, equality, and human rights. It is a reminder that the fight for a just society includes standing up for those who are often silenced and overlooked, ensuring that their stories and struggles are acknowledged in the broader narrative of our nation.
The tragic death of Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez, a 52-year-old Guatemalan immigrant, following an enforcement operation by ICE at a Home Depot in Monrovia, California, underscores the dire consequences of our nation's immigration policies. As more than 300 mourners gathered to honor Montoya Valdez, their collective grief transformed into a poignant critique of a system that prioritizes enforcement and fear over compassion and community safety. This incident serves as a stark reminder of the human cost of aggressive immigration enforcement, a legacy that has been exacerbated in recent years.
Historically, the United States has had a complicated relationship with immigration, often oscillating between welcoming newcomers and imposing strict barriers. The current climate, marked by heightened enforcement under the Trump Administration and continuing under subsequent leadership, reflects a trend toward dehumanizing immigrants rather than recognizing their contributions to society. Montoya Valdez's story is emblematic of countless individuals who, driven by desperation and hope for a better life, find themselves in perilous situations when confronted with the harsh realities of immigration enforcement. The instinct to flee in the face of authority reflects not just personal fear but also a deeply ingrained societal fear—one that has been cultivated by aggressive policies and rhetoric.
To address this ongoing crisis, Americans must engage in conversations that challenge the status quo. We can advocate for policies that prioritize the well-being and safety of all individuals, regardless of their immigration status. This means calling for a reevaluation of ICE's role in our communities, pushing for reforms that protect rather than endanger, and supporting local initiatives that foster inclusive environments. The outpouring of support for Montoya Valdez at the vigil is a testament to community solidarity; it shows that people are willing to stand against policies that tear families apart and create fear.
Educational initiatives can also play a critical role in shifting perspectives. By raising awareness about the realities faced by immigrants—such as the challenges of navigating a system that often feels hostile—advocates can help dismantle the stereotypes that fuel anti-immigrant sentiment. Hosting community forums, sharing personal stories, and utilizing social media platforms to amplify voices like Montoya Valdez's can create a ripple effect, encouraging empathy and understanding. Engaging in these dialogues not only humanizes the immigrant experience but also emphasizes the shared values of safety and dignity for all.
Finally, we must take concrete actions at the local level to support our immigrant communities. This can involve volunteering with organizations that provide legal assistance, advocating for sanctuary policies, and promoting local measures that limit the cooperation between local law enforcement and federal immigration authorities. As we honor Montoya Valdez's memory, let's channel our grief into action—ensuring that his story serves not just as a tragic reminder but as a catalyst for change. Collectively, we can work towards a society that values every individual’s humanity, fostering communities rooted in respect and solidarity, rather than fear and division.
The tragic death of Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez highlights the urgent need to address the ongoing issues surrounding immigration enforcement and the safety of individuals in our communities. Here's a detailed list of actions that individuals can take to address this situation and advocate for change.
### What Can We Personally Do About This?
1. **Educate Yourself and Others**: Understanding immigration laws, ICE practices, and the impact of enforcement on communities is crucial. Share this knowledge with friends, family, and social networks to raise awareness.
2. **Support Local Organizations**: Engage with organizations that advocate for immigrant rights and provide support to affected communities. Volunteer time, donate resources, or help spread their message.
3. **Attend Community Meetings**: Participate in local town halls and community discussions about immigration enforcement and community safety. Voice your concerns and listen to the experiences of others.
4. **Engage with Elected Officials**: Hold local representatives accountable by advocating for humane immigration policies. Contact them regularly to express your views on enforcement practices and community safety.
### Exact Actions We Can Take
1. **Petitions**: - **Sign a Petition**: Look for petitions addressing the need for immigration reform and humane treatment of immigrants. For instance, Change.org often has active petitions related to immigration issues. - **Create Your Own Petition**: If you don’t find one that resonates, consider starting a petition calling for local government changes in immigration enforcement policies. You can utilize platforms like MoveOn.org or Care2 Petitions.
2. **Contact Elected Officials**: - **Write to Your Representatives**: Here are some key figures you might consider writing to, along with their contact details: - **Senator Alex Padilla** (California): - Email: padilla.senate.gov/contact - **Senator Dianne Feinstein** (California): - Email: feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/e-mail-me - **Representative Judy Chu** (California 27th District): - Email: chu.house.gov/contact/email-judy - **Message Template**: ``` Subject: Urgent Need for Immigration Policy Reform
Dear [Official’s Name],
I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the tragic death of Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez, which underscores the dangers posed by current immigration enforcement practices. This incident highlights the urgent need for reform to ensure the safety and dignity of all individuals in our communities, regardless of their immigration status.
I urge you to advocate for policies that prioritize community safety and protect vulnerable populations from fear-based enforcement actions. Please consider supporting measures that limit ICE collaborations with local law enforcement and promote pathways for comprehensive immigration reform.
Thank you for your attention to this vital issue.
Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Address] [Your Contact Information] ```
3. **Organize or Attend Vigils**: Participate in or organize vigils to honor individuals who have lost their lives due to immigration enforcement actions. This can raise awareness and foster community solidarity.
4. **Share Stories**: Use social media platforms to share Roberto’s story and similar incidents. Utilize hashtags related to immigration rights to help your posts reach a wider audience.
5. **Support Immigrant Workers**: If possible, hire immigrant workers or support local businesses that employ them. This helps to create an environment where immigrant contributions are recognized and valued.
6. **Advocate for Local Policies**: Work with community groups to advocate for local policies that protect immigrant rights, such as sanctuary city policies or local ordinances that limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
By taking these actions, we can contribute to a more compassionate and just approach to immigration enforcement in our communities. Each step, no matter how small, contributes to a larger movement advocating for the rights and dignity of all individuals.