COMMENTARY: Washington, D.C.: Then and now | Jefferson City News-Tribune
newstribune.com -- Friday, August 15, 2025, 5:23:35 AM Eastern Daylight Time
Categories: Presidential Campaigns, Democratic Party Responses
I was born in Washington, D.C., at the end of 1942. Growing up in the suburbs there was so little crime it made the front page in the city's three newspapers. Today, unless someone who works on Capitol Hill is murdered, or associated with a prominent business, stories are usually buried in the Metro section. Then, you could walk the streets at night, and feel safe. Now, you take your life in your hands.
President Trump has ordered National Guard troops into the city to help DC police control violent crime.
As U.S. Attorney for DC Jeanine Pirro noted at a White House news conference Monday, many teen criminals are assigned to family court where "they are sent to yoga and art classes. That changes today." Video of store lootings are so common they have lost their shock value.
There are facts, lies and statistics, as the saying goes, and Democrats are claiming statistics show violent crime is down in D.C.
A D.C. police commander is under investigation for allegedly making changes to crime statistics in his district. The police union claims supervisors in the department manipulate crime data to make it appear violent crime has fallen considerably compared to last year.
The White House has issued a list comparing actual DC crime statistics with other cities and countries:
In 2024, Washington, D.C., saw a homicide rate of 27.3 per 100,000 residents. That was the fourth-highest homicide rate in the country -- nearly six times higher than New York City and also higher than Atlanta, Chicago and Compton.
If Washington, D.C., was a state, it would have the highest homicide rate of any state in the nation.
In 2012, the homicide rate in Washington, D.C. was just 13.9 per 100,000 residents.
Washington, D.C.'s murder rate is roughly three times higher than that of Islamabad, Pakistan, and 18 times higher than that of communist-run Havana, Cuba.
The number of juveniles arrested in Washington, D.C., has gone up each year since 2020 -- many of whom have had prior arrests for violent crimes.
There were 29,348 crimes reported in Washington, D.C. last year, including 3,469 violent offenses, 1,026 assaults with a dangerous weapon, 2,113 robberies, and 5,139 motor vehicle thefts.
So far in 2025, there have already been nearly 1,600 violent crimes and nearly 16,000 total crimes reported in Washington, D.C.
There have been nearly 100 homicides, including the fatal shootings of innocent civilians like three-year-old Honesty Cheadle and 21-year-old Capitol Hill intern Eric Tarpinian-Jachym.
Vehicle theft in Washington, D.C. is more than three times the national average-- ranking it among the most dangerous cities in the world.
Carjackings increased 547 percent between 2018 and 2023.
In 2024, there were triple the number of carjackings compared to 2018.
These statistics are not only troubling on their own, but they also likely significantly understate the level of crime in Washington, D.C.
Many residents don't feel safe reporting crime.
More than half of all violent crime in the U.S. goes unreported.
WUSA-TV: "D.C. residents voice frustration over rising violence, questioning police stats and demanding real action to make neighborhoods feel safe again."
CNN notes: "Extending the takeover for a longer period requires Trump to formally notify the chairs and ranking members of congressional committees handling DC affairs. Any control lasting more than 30 days would need congressional approval and must be passed into law, a highly improbable scenario given the current gridlock in a closely divided Congress."
Area residents know what needs to happen in addition to swift punishment of the perpetrators. They include employed fathers in the home and school choice to free especially poor kids from failing public schools that give them nothing on which to build a life. Without these the National Guard will only be a temporary fix.
Readers may email Cal Thomas at [email protected]. Look for Cal Thomas' latest book "A Watchman in the Night: What I've Seen Over 50 Years Reporting on America" (HumanixBooks).
Sign Our PetitionThe recent commentary on crime in Washington, D.C. provides a stark reminder of the complex and often politicized nature of urban violence in America. The author reflects on a nostalgic past where crime was minimal, contrasting it with today’s situation where crime statistics dominate the headlines. However, this perspective requires careful examination, particularly in the context of systemic social issues that have long plagued urban centers, including economic inequality, historical racism, and the failure of public policy to address root causes of crime.
Historically, Washington, D.C. has been a microcosm of broader American societal issues. The city has been shaped by deep-seated inequalities, stemming from its history of racial segregation and economic disenfranchisement. The War on Drugs, initiated in the 1980s, disproportionately targeted communities of color, leading to mass incarceration and a legacy of trauma that still reverberates today. Instead of investing in communities through education and social services, government responses have often leaned towards punitive measures. The invocation of the National Guard to restore order reflects a tendency to resort to militarization rather than addressing the underlying socioeconomic factors that contribute to crime.
Moreover, the commentary touches upon the manipulation of crime statistics, a practice that raises significant concerns about transparency and accountability in law enforcement. The assertion that crime data may be altered to present a more favorable view of public safety echoes a broader conversation about police practices and the need for reform. The public's trust in law enforcement is contingent upon honesty and integrity in reporting, and any deviation from this can exacerbate feelings of fear and insecurity among residents. Rather than focusing solely on crime rates, a more nuanced approach that considers the context of these figures is essential for fostering safety and security in communities.
Another critical angle to consider is the economic context in which crime occurs. The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated existing economic inequalities, pushing many families into precarious situations. Job losses, housing instability, and lack of access to mental health services have compounded the challenges faced by vulnerable populations, particularly youth. When discussing juvenile crime, it is crucial to recognize that many young people are not inherently violent; rather, they are often responding to the pressures of their environment. Programs that prioritize rehabilitation, education, and community engagement have shown promising results, suggesting that investment in social infrastructure, rather than punitive measures, is a more effective means of reducing crime.
Furthermore, the commentary’s comparison of Washington, D.C.'s crime rates to those of international cities raises pertinent questions about the societal conditions that foster safety and security. Cities like Havana, Cuba, and Islamabad, Pakistan, have different social contracts, with varying approaches to public safety and community support. This comparison underscores the importance of considering how social services, economic equity, and community involvement can create safer environments. The narrative that associates crime with individual failure, rather than systemic failure, serves to distract from the need for comprehensive policy changes that address the root causes of violence.
In conclusion, while the increase in crime in Washington, D.C. is alarming and necessitates urgent attention, it is equally important to approach the issue through a lens that acknowledges the historical and social justice contexts. The conversation should not be limited to statistics and sensational incidents but rather expanded to include discussions about economic inequality, systemic racism, and the effectiveness of community-based interventions. By prioritizing investment in social programs and community support, we can begin to address the complex web of factors contributing to urban crime and work towards a safer, more equitable society for all.
The commentary on crime rates in Washington, D.C., as discussed in the article, sheds light on a complex and multifaceted issue that extends beyond mere statistics. The historical context of crime in urban centers, particularly in the nation's capital, is essential for understanding the current landscape. In the mid-20th century, D.C. was characterized by its relatively low crime rates and a sense of safety that allowed residents to roam freely at night. However, the social and economic dynamics that have shaped urban America since the 1970s—including deindustrialization, systemic racism, and the war on drugs—have contributed to a troubling rise in violence and crime in many urban areas, including D.C. This historical backdrop is necessary to grasp how deeply ingrained issues manifest in the contemporary landscape.
One cannot ignore the broader political narratives that influence public perception and responses to crime. The article highlights how political figures, such as President Trump and U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, frame crime in sensational terms, often invoking fear to justify increased policing and military presence in cities. While it is crucial to address public safety, an over-reliance on punitive measures fails to consider the root causes of crime. The discussion around teen criminals receiving rehabilitation through programs like yoga and art classes is often dismissed as ineffective, yet such initiatives can be vital in addressing the underlying trauma and socio-economic factors that lead to criminal behavior. The challenge lies in shifting the conversation from one of punishment to one of prevention and rehabilitation.
As concerned citizens, we must consider what action we can take to address the issues of crime without resorting to fear-mongering or punitive policies. First and foremost, advocating for community-based programs that focus on education, mental health services, and economic opportunities can create safer neighborhoods. Investing in youth programs that provide mentorship, job training, and recreational activities can help divert young individuals from potential criminal activity. Additionally, fostering community-police relations through transparency and accountability can improve trust and collaboration between law enforcement and the communities they serve. By prioritizing restorative justice practices, we can work towards healing rather than further marginalizing individuals caught in the cycle of crime.
Moreover, understanding the implications of crime statistics and their manipulation is essential for an informed citizenry. The article raises concerns about the integrity of crime data reporting, emphasizing the importance of accurate statistics in shaping policy responses. As citizens, we must demand transparency from local governments regarding crime data and hold police departments accountable for any discrepancies. Furthermore, advocating for independent oversight of police practices can ensure that policing strategies are effective and just, rather than merely reactive to public fear.
In conclusion, the conversation surrounding crime in Washington, D.C., and other urban areas must evolve beyond sensational headlines and political posturing. It is essential to recognize crime as a symptom of deeper societal issues rather than an isolated problem. By advocating for systemic changes that prioritize social equity, community engagement, and rehabilitation, we can build a safer and more just society. As citizens, our role in this endeavor is to engage, educate, and advocate for policies that foster healing and opportunity, ultimately creating a safer environment for all. This approach not only addresses immediate concerns but also lays the groundwork for long-term solutions that benefit communities across the nation.
To address the issues highlighted in the article concerning crime in Washington, D.C., we can take a variety of personal actions aimed at promoting community safety, accountability, and systemic change. Here’s a detailed list of ideas and actions we can undertake:
### 1. **Advocate for Comprehensive Community Safety Programs** - **Action:** Support initiatives that focus on community-based safety programs instead of militarized responses to crime. This could include investing in mental health services, youth programs, and community engagement projects. - **Example:** Join or support organizations like the Urban Institute or the Coalition for Police Accountability that advocate for these types of community programs.
### 2. **Engage with Local Representatives** - **Who to Write To:** Contact your local city council members and representatives to express your concerns and urge them to prioritize community safety and transparency in crime reporting. - **Names and Emails:** - **Mayor Muriel Bowser**: muriel.bowser@dc.gov - **DC Council Members** (you can find your representative at [DC Council website](https://dccouncil.us/about-the-council/council-members/)): - **What to Say:** Emphasize the importance of community-driven safety initiatives and the need for transparency in crime statistics. Request that they hold police departments accountable for accurate reporting and focus on crime prevention through social services.
### 3. **Support Youth Programs** - **Action:** Volunteer or donate to local organizations focused on youth engagement and rehabilitation, such as the Boys & Girls Clubs of Greater Washington. - **Example:** Organize fundraisers or awareness campaigns to raise funds for after-school programs or mentorship initiatives designed to keep youth out of the criminal justice system.
### 4. **Participate in Local Crime Reduction Initiatives** - **Action:** Attend local neighborhood meetings and participate in community policing forums to discuss concerns and collaborate on solutions. - **Example:** Engage with programs like "Neighborhood Watch" to foster community vigilance and proactive measures against crime.
### 5. **Petitions for Transparency in Crime Data** - **Action:** Create or sign petitions demanding more transparent crime reporting from the police department and an independent review of crime statistics. - **Example:** Use platforms like Change.org to initiate a petition, targeting both local government officials and the police department for accountability in crime data reporting.
### 6. **Educate Yourself and Others** - **Action:** Host or participate in community discussions and workshops focusing on crime trends, prevention strategies, and community resilience. - **Example:** Partner with local universities or civic organizations to organize educational seminars about the socioeconomic factors contributing to crime.
### 7. **Support Policy Reform** - **Who to Write To:** Contact state and federal representatives advocating for policy reforms that address root causes of crime, including poverty, education, and mental health. - **Names and Emails:** - **Senator Chris Van Hollen**: vanhollen.senate.gov - **Senator Ben Cardin**: cardin.senate.gov - **What to Say:** Advocate for policies that address systemic issues contributing to crime, such as increasing funding for mental health services and education, and reforming the juvenile justice system to focus on rehabilitation.
### 8. **Promote Alternatives to Incarceration** - **Action:** Support legislative measures that promote alternatives to incarceration for non-violent offenders. - **Example:** Write to your representatives urging them to support legislation like the "Youth Offender Rehabilitation Act" or similar bills focusing on rehabilitation rather than punishment.
### 9. **Engage in Local Media** - **Action:** Write op-eds or letters to the editor in local publications to raise awareness about crime issues and promote constructive solutions. - **Example:** Submit a thoughtful piece to the Washington Post or other local newspapers discussing community safety and the need for data integrity in crime reporting.
### 10. **Build Alliances with Advocacy Groups** - **Action:** Collaborate with advocacy groups focused on criminal justice reform and community safety. - **Example:** Connect with organizations like the ACLU or the Brennan Center for Justice to learn about their ongoing initiatives and how you can help.
By taking these actions, individuals can contribute to a more informed, engaged, and proactive community that seeks to address the complexities of crime in Washington, D.C. and work towards lasting change.