Final arguments in Jimmy Lai's national security trial in Hong Kong delayed over health concerns - WTOP News
wtop.com -- Friday, August 15, 2025, 12:38:52 AM Eastern Daylight Time
Categories: U.S.–China Relations, Media Coverage & Press Relations, Presidential Campaigns
HONG KONG (AP) -- The final arguments in prominent Hong Kong activist Jimmy Lai's national security trial were postponed Friday after his lawyer said the former pro-democracy newspaper founder had experienced heart palpitations and the judges wanted him to receive medical treatment first.
Lai, the 77-year-old founder of the now-defunct Apple Daily newspaper, was arrested in 2020 under a national security law imposed by Beijing following anti-government protests in 2019. He faces charges of colluding with foreign forces to endanger national security and conspiring with others to issue seditious publications. If convicted, he faces up to life imprisonment.
Lai's landmark case -- which has already lasted over 140 days, far beyond the original estimate of 80 days -- is widely seen as a trial of press freedom and a test for judicial independence in the Asian financial hub.
Closing statements were initially scheduled to begin on Thursday, but were postponed due to heavy rains from Tropical Storm Podul.
On Friday, Lai's lawyer, Robert Pang, told the court that Lai felt unsteady and had experienced heart palpitations. Pang said his client does not want to disturb the court proceedings.
Judge Esther Toh said Lai had not received medication and a heart monitor, as recommended by a medical specialist. The judges decided to postpone the hearing until Monday.
When Lai entered the courtroom, he smiled and nodded at people sitting in the public gallery.
Lai's detention has drawn attention from foreign governments. U.S. President Donald Trump, before the election last November, was asked whether he would talk to Chinese leader Xi Jinping to seek Lai's release, and Trump said: "One hundred percent, I will get him out."
In a Fox News radio interview released Thursday, Trump denied saying he would "100%" save Lai. "I said, 100%, I'm going to be bringing it up. And I've already brought it up, and I'm going to do everything I can to save him," he said.
Lai's son and rights groups have voiced concerns about his health. His son Sebastien Lai earlier told reporters in Washington that he fears his father could pass away at any time.
On Tuesday, global media watchdog Reporters Without Borders said Lai has been held in solidarity confinement for over 1,680 days and that his health is deteriorating. In a statement, it called for the international community to take action to ensure the immediate release of Lai and six other former Apple Daily executives involved in the case.
But the Hong Kong government rejected in a statement on Wednesday what it called "slanderous remarks" by external forces, including "anti-China media organizations," about the case and Lai's custody treatment.
Ahead of the hearing, dozens of people lined up outside the court building to secure a seat in the main courtroom. Some of them also waited for hours in heavy rain on Thursday before the postponement, including resident Margaret Chan.
Chan, who arrived before 5:30 a.m. on Friday, said Lai's case showed the world the decline in Hong Kong's press freedom.
"To me, he's a great person. He made such a big sacrifice. He's so rich. He could have predicted this, and he could have left," said Chan.
Copyright © 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.
Sign Our PetitionThe ongoing trial of Jimmy Lai, a prominent figure in the pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong, has become emblematic of the broader struggle for fundamental rights and freedoms in the region. Lai’s case is not merely about one individual facing charges under the controversial national security law imposed by Beijing; it represents the systematic dismantling of civil liberties and press freedom in Hong Kong. His trial, which has already extended beyond 140 days, serves as a critical juncture in the historical context of Hong Kong’s autonomy and the increasing authoritarianism of the Chinese government.
The historical backdrop of Lai’s situation is crucial to understanding the current events unfolding in Hong Kong. The 2019 protests, sparked by a proposed extradition bill, were a response to years of encroaching control from Beijing over the semi-autonomous territory. These protests galvanized a diverse coalition of citizens who sought to uphold the liberties guaranteed under the Sino-British Joint Declaration and the Basic Law, Hong Kong’s mini-constitution. The implementation of the national security law in 2020 marked a turning point, effectively criminalizing dissent and enabling the Hong Kong government to suppress political opposition with impunity. In this context, Lai’s arrest and subsequent trial serve as a stark reminder of the lengths to which the state will go to quell dissent and silence voices advocating for democracy and human rights.
Lai’s health issues during the trial, including reported heart palpitations and the necessity for medical intervention, raise significant questions about the treatment of political prisoners in Hong Kong. Reports from human rights organizations like Reporters Without Borders highlight the deteriorating health of Lai, who has been held in solitary confinement for over 1,680 days. This situation reflects a broader pattern of neglect and mistreatment of detainees, particularly those labeled as political dissidents. Such treatment not only contravenes international human rights standards but also underscores the urgent need for global advocacy and intervention. The international community must respond to these injustices, as failure to do so risks tacitly endorsing the authoritarian tactics employed by the Hong Kong government.
Moreover, Lai’s case has garnered international attention, bringing together a coalition of governments, NGOs, and advocates who recognize that the fight for press freedom is intrinsically linked to the broader struggle for democracy worldwide. The statements made by figures such as President Trump, while politically charged, reflect a growing awareness of the implications of Lai’s trial for global human rights norms. It is essential to recognize that the fight for democracy in Hong Kong is not an isolated event; it is part of a larger narrative of resistance against authoritarianism seen in various forms globally, whether in Belarus, Myanmar, or elsewhere. This interconnectedness of social struggles reminds us that the fight for justice is universal and requires solidarity across borders.
The trial of Jimmy Lai is thus not just a legal matter; it symbolizes the ongoing battle against the erosion of democratic values in Hong Kong and beyond. As Lai’s supporters continue to gather outside the courtroom, braving heavy rains and the oppressive weight of state power, they embody the spirit of resistance against tyranny. This struggle is about more than just one man’s plight; it is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit in the face of oppression. As the world watches, it is imperative that we acknowledge and support these efforts, advocating for the release of political prisoners and the preservation of press freedom as fundamental human rights. Engaging in conversations about Lai's case can serve as a powerful reminder of the importance of defending democracy, not just in Hong Kong, but across the globe.
The postponement of Jimmy Lai's trial brings to the forefront not only the troubling state of judicial independence in Hong Kong but also a broader narrative about freedom of speech and the right to dissent in an increasingly authoritarian world. Lai, a prominent figure in the pro-democracy movement and founder of the now-defunct Apple Daily newspaper, symbolizes the struggle for press freedom in a city once celebrated for its vibrant civil society. His prolonged detention and deteriorating health reflect the extent to which the Chinese government is willing to go to suppress dissent and control narratives, a trend that raises alarm bells not only for those within Hong Kong but for democracy advocates globally.
Historically, Hong Kong has been a bastion of freedoms and individual rights, particularly following its handover from British rule in 1997. The Sino-British Joint Declaration promised a "high degree of autonomy" and the preservation of fundamental rights, including freedom of the press. However, recent years have seen a dramatic erosion of these freedoms, particularly following the implementation of the National Security Law in 2020. This law, criticized as a tool for silencing dissent, has led to a chilling effect on journalists and activists alike. Lai's case exemplifies this alarming trend, as his charges of colluding with foreign forces and issuing seditious publications are broadly defined and can be applied to a wide range of political activities.
As we observe this situation unfold, it is crucial to consider the actions that Americans, and indeed global citizens, can take to advocate for justice and human rights. Firstly, raising awareness is essential. Social media platforms and community forums can be powerful tools to share Lai’s story and the broader implications of his trial. Engaging in discussions about the importance of press freedom and the dangers of authoritarianism can help mobilize public opinion and put pressure on governments to act. Grassroots campaigns can amplify calls for action, urging lawmakers to prioritize foreign policy that supports human rights and democratic values.
Moreover, we can leverage our political systems to advocate for policies that hold authoritarian regimes accountable. This could include supporting legislation that imposes sanctions on officials involved in human rights abuses in Hong Kong and collaborating with international coalitions to push for the release of political prisoners like Lai. Advocacy organizations play a critical role in these efforts, and supporting their work, whether through donations or volunteer efforts, can amplify the impact of their campaigns. Engaging with local representatives to express concerns about Hong Kong’s deteriorating human rights situation can also pressure them to take a stand.
In addition, educational initiatives can play a significant role in fostering a culture of awareness and activism. Schools and universities can incorporate discussions on global human rights issues, using cases like Lai’s as a springboard into larger conversations about civic responsibility and global citizenship. Such educational efforts can empower the next generation to advocate for justice and understand the interconnectedness of global struggles for freedom.
In conclusion, the case of Jimmy Lai serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of democracy and the critical importance of protecting press freedom and individual rights. It calls upon us not only to witness the unfolding events but also to take action in our own communities. By raising awareness, advocating for policy changes, and fostering educational initiatives, we can contribute to a global movement that stands in solidarity with those who dare to speak truth to power. As Lai awaits the next steps in his trial, we must ensure that his fight—and the fight for democracy in Hong Kong—does not go unnoticed.
The ongoing trial of Jimmy Lai, a prominent pro-democracy activist in Hong Kong, serves as a stark reminder of the critical importance of press freedom and human rights globally. As concerned individuals, there are several actions we can take to advocate for Lai’s release and raise awareness about the broader implications of his case. Here’s a detailed list of ideas and actions we can personally undertake:
### 1. **Raise Awareness and Educate Others** - **Host Informational Sessions:** Organize community gatherings to discuss the issues surrounding press freedom and human rights in Hong Kong. Utilize social media to reach a wider audience. - **Share Articles and Resources:** Share articles, videos, and resources about Jimmy Lai’s case on social media platforms to inform and engage others.
### 2. **Petition for Action** - **Create or Sign Petitions:** Use platforms like Change.org or GoPetition to start or sign petitions demanding the release of Jimmy Lai and the protection of press freedom in Hong Kong. A specific petition can be aimed at international leaders, urging them to take action. - **Example Petition:** "Free Jimmy Lai – Stand Up for Press Freedom" (look for similar petitions online to support).
### 3. **Contact Elected Officials** - **Write to Your Representatives:** Draft letters to local and national representatives urging them to advocate for Jimmy Lai’s release. Your voice matters, and representatives often pay attention to constituents' concerns. - **Sample Contacts:** - **U.S. Senate:** You can find your senator's contact information through [www.senate.gov](https://www.senate.gov). Look for the “Find Your Senator” tool. - **U.S. House of Representatives:** Use [www.house.gov](https://www.house.gov) to locate your representative.
- **What to Say:** In your letter, express your concerns about Lai’s health and the implications of his detention on press freedom. Urge them to take a strong stance against the Chinese government’s actions.
### 4. **Support Human Rights Organizations** - **Donate or Volunteer:** Support organizations such as Reporters Without Borders, Amnesty International, or Human Rights Watch that are actively advocating for Jimmy Lai and others in similar situations. - **Reporters Without Borders Contact:** - **Website:** [www.rsf.org](https://rsf.org/en) - **Email:** contact@rsf.org - **Address:** 47, rue Vivienne, 75002 Paris, France. ### 5. **Engage with Media** - **Write Op-Eds or Letters to the Editor:** Submit opinion pieces or letters to local newspapers discussing the importance of press freedom and highlighting Jimmy Lai’s case. - **Contact Major News Outlets:** Encourage major news outlets to cover the issue by reaching out to them with your concerns and emphasizing the global interest in Lai’s case.
### 6. **Utilize Social Media Campaigns** - **Join or Create Hashtags:** Participate in campaigns on platforms like Twitter and Instagram using hashtags like #FreeJimmyLai or #PressFreedom. - **Share Personal Stories:** Encourage others to share why press freedom matters to them, connecting personal stories to the broader issue.
### 7. **Engage in Direct Protest** - **Participate in or Organize Rallies:** Join or organize local protests or demonstrations advocating for Jimmy Lai and press freedom. Make signs and use slogans that highlight the urgency of the situation. - **Virtual Protests:** If in-person protests are not feasible, consider organizing online events or webinars to discuss these issues and mobilize support.
### 8. **Stay Informed** - **Follow Updates:** Keep track of developments in Jimmy Lai’s trial and the situation in Hong Kong by following reliable news sources and human rights organizations. - **Join Mailing Lists:** Subscribe to newsletters from organizations focusing on human rights and press freedom to receive timely updates.
By taking these actions, we can collectively raise our voices for Jimmy Lai and the broader struggle for democracy and press freedom, sending a message that the international community will not stand idly by in the face of such injustice.