Noem: 1.6M Illegal Immigrants Leaving Is 'Massive'
kvor.com -- Friday, August 15, 2025, 4:29:13 PM Eastern Daylight Time
Categories: Immigration Policy & Border Issues, Public Opinion & Polling, Presidential Campaigns
Approximately 1.6 million people without legal immigration status have left the United States since the start of the Trump administration, according to Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem.
"In less than 200 days, 1.6 MILLION illegal immigrants have left the United States population. This is massive," Noem said in a social media post thanking President Donald Trump.
She added that the decrease would yield safer streets, reduced taxpayer spending, less burden on schools and hospitals and improved job prospects for Americans.
The figure comes from a report by the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), a group that supports lower immigration levels but has acknowledged its estimate may overstate the decline.
The Department of Homeland Security said the claim is based on CIS's analysis of data from the Current Population Survey (CPS), administered by the Census Bureau and Bureau of Labor Statistics. The CPS collects information on birthplace and citizenship, but does not ask respondents about immigration status.
CIS noted several caveats in its methodology. It said increased enforcement measures may have led to fewer immigrants responding to the survey, possibly exaggerating the apparent drop.
The center also said its data on legal immigration through July 2025 is incomplete, adding further uncertainty to the estimate.
Current estimates place the number of undocumented individuals in the U.S. at around 13 million.
Researchers say that due to changes in enforcement, some migrants may now avoid participation in government surveys.
Julia Gelatt of the Migration Policy Institute said that because information from records for Medicaid, food stamps, and other government programs may now be shared with immigration authorities, immigrants without secure legal status might be reluctant to respond, especially given the CPS's small sample size.
The CIS figure of 1.6 million has drawn skepticism. In April, the administration reported 135,000 deportations, a number that the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) said was exaggerated, estimating actual deportations at closer to 72,000.
TRAC also reported that immigration judges issued deportation orders for just over 360,000 individuals this year, though it is unclear when many of these removals will take place.
In addition to enforcement actions, the administration has introduced incentives for voluntary departures, offering $1,000 to those who register to leave via the CBP Home App, which replaced an earlier asylum request application.
The administration has also moved to terminate Temporary Protected Status programs and parole options created under the Biden administration, and ICE attorneys have sought dismissal of some immigration cases to enable expedited removal proceedings.
Sign Our PetitionThe recent comments by Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem regarding the exit of approximately 1.6 million undocumented immigrants from the United States since the beginning of the Trump administration offer a stark illustration of the ongoing narrative surrounding immigration in the country. By framing this exodus as a "massive" success, Noem aligns herself with a politicized agenda that seeks to portray immigration as a threat to national security and economic stability. This rhetoric is not merely about numbers; it reflects a broader ideological framework that scapegoats immigrants for a variety of societal issues. Understanding the historical and social context of immigration in the United States allows for a deeper examination of these claims and their implications.
Historically, the United States has been a nation built on immigration, with waves of newcomers contributing to its cultural, economic, and social fabric. From the Irish and Italian immigrants of the late 19th century to the more recent influx from Central America and beyond, immigrants have played an essential role in shaping American society. The current administration’s approach, which includes the demonization of immigrants, represents a significant departure from the country’s foundational principles. The use of terms like "illegal" to describe undocumented individuals dehumanizes them and ignores their contributions. It is critical to recognize that many immigrants are fleeing violence, persecution, and economic hardship, often seeking refuge in a country that has long touted itself as a land of opportunity.
Moreover, the data cited by Noem comes from the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), an organization with a clear bias toward restricting immigration. Their methodologies and conclusions are often criticized for lacking rigor, and independent experts have raised significant doubts about the accuracy of their estimates. For instance, the Current Population Survey (CPS) that underpins CIS's claims does not directly inquire about immigration status, which raises questions about the validity of the findings. This highlights a broader issue in the immigration debate: data is frequently manipulated to support pre-existing narratives. The reluctance of undocumented immigrants to participate in surveys due to fears of deportation further complicates the reliability of such estimates, revealing a vicious cycle of misinformation that fuels anti-immigrant sentiment.
The implications of these policies are profound, affecting not only the lives of immigrants but also the communities they inhabit. The assertion that reduced numbers of undocumented immigrants will lead to "safer streets" and "improved job prospects" is unfounded and oversimplified. Numerous studies indicate that immigrants are less likely to engage in criminal activities compared to native-born citizens. In fact, immigrant communities often contribute to community safety and economic vitality. By embracing an exclusionary approach to immigration, policymakers are ignoring the myriad ways in which immigrants enhance local economies, fill labor shortages, and contribute to the tax base that supports public services like schools and hospitals.
Furthermore, the Trump administration's strategies to incentivize voluntary departures and expedite removals echo a troubling historical precedent where immigration policy has been weaponized against marginalized communities. The termination of Temporary Protected Status programs and the dismantling of pathways for legal relief underscore a systemic pattern of exclusion that disproportionately affects vulnerable populations, particularly people of color. Such actions not only create a climate of fear but also undermine the social fabric of communities that rely on the diversity and contributions of immigrant populations. The ongoing struggles for justice and equity in the immigration system are part of a larger movement for human rights that demands recognition of the inherent dignity of all individuals, regardless of legal status.
In summary, the discourse surrounding immigration, as illustrated by Noem's remarks, is fraught with historical inaccuracies and social injustices. The simplistic portrayal of immigration as a burden ignores the rich contributions of immigrants to American society and perpetuates a narrative that serves political ends. To engage in fruitful discussions about immigration policy, it is essential to ground arguments in facts and a historical understanding of the role of immigrants in shaping the nation. Advocates for social justice must continue to challenge the prevailing narratives and advocate for policies that respect the rights and dignity of all individuals, recognizing that the fight for immigrant rights is intrinsically linked to broader struggles for equity and justice in society.
The recent statement from Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem, which claims that approximately 1.6 million undocumented immigrants have left the United States since the start of the Trump administration, raises significant questions about the accuracy and implications of such figures. This assertion is rooted in a report from the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), an organization known for its restrictive stance on immigration and whose methodology has been met with skepticism. The broader implications of these claims, especially within the context of historical immigration trends and enforcement policies, provide fertile ground for discussion and action regarding immigration reform and the treatment of immigrants in American society.
Historical context is critical in understanding the dynamics behind immigration in the United States. For decades, immigrants have played an essential role in the country’s economic and cultural fabric. Yet, the political landscape has shifted significantly, particularly during the Trump administration, which adopted a hardline approach to immigration. This included increased deportations, a crackdown on asylum seekers, and the promotion of policies that foster fear and distrust among immigrant communities. The claim that a vast number of undocumented immigrants have left the U.S. is not only misleading but also serves to reinforce harmful narratives that criminalize immigrants and suggest they are a burden on American society. By dissecting the language used in such statements, we can better articulate the need for a compassionate and fact-based approach to immigration.
Moreover, the methods used by organizations like CIS to arrive at these figures are fraught with inconsistencies. The reliance on the Current Population Survey (CPS) raises concerns about the accuracy of data, especially considering the fear that many immigrants may have of disclosing their status due to increased surveillance and enforcement actions. This situation is exacerbated by the politicization of immigration enforcement, where policies intended to protect public safety can lead to the marginalization of entire communities. Understanding these nuances allows us to engage in more informed discussions about immigration, challenging the assumptions perpetuated by right-wing narratives that equate undocumented status with criminality and economic strain.
In light of these issues, there are actionable steps that Americans can take to advocate for a more just and humane immigration policy. First, promoting education and awareness about the realities of immigration and the contributions of immigrants to society is crucial. By sharing accurate information, engaging in community conversations, and providing platforms for immigrant voices, we can counteract the misinformation that fuels anti-immigrant sentiment. Grassroots organizations and local advocacy groups play a vital role in this effort, as they often have firsthand accounts of the immigrant experience and can mobilize communities to stand in solidarity with those affected by harsh immigration policies.
Additionally, advocating for legislative changes that support immigrant rights is essential. This includes pushing for pathways to citizenship, the reinstatement of programs like Temporary Protected Status, and the protection of asylum rights. Engaging with elected officials, participating in town hall meetings, and supporting candidates who prioritize humane immigration reform can create lasting change. It is also vital to hold government agencies accountable for their actions, demanding transparency in immigration enforcement and ensuring that the rights of all individuals, regardless of their immigration status, are upheld.
In conclusion, the rhetoric surrounding immigration remains a contentious battleground in American politics. By critically analyzing statements like Noem's, understanding the historical context, and advocating for immigrants' rights, we can foster a more inclusive dialogue about immigration. It is imperative to dismantle the harmful narratives that seek to alienate and dehumanize immigrants, recognizing instead the vital role they play in our society. Through education, advocacy, and community engagement, we can work towards a future that upholds the principles of dignity and respect for all individuals, regardless of their legal status.
The article presents a complex issue surrounding immigration and the narratives being spun around it. It’s important to approach this situation with an understanding of the human aspects involved and consider actions that can contribute to a more just and humane immigration system.
### What Can We Personally Do About This?
1. **Educate Yourself and Others**: Understanding the nuances of immigration policy is crucial. Read comprehensive sources about immigration, including data, personal stories, and policy implications. Share this information with friends and family to help dispel myths.
2. **Engage in Local Activism**: Get involved with local organizations that advocate for immigrant rights. This can include volunteering, attending meetings, or participating in campaigns.
3. **Support Immigrant Communities**: Offer assistance to local immigrant communities. This might involve tutoring, providing legal aid, or simply being a friend and ally.
4. **Advocate for Fair Policies**: Write to your representatives and advocate for humane immigration policies that protect the rights of all individuals regardless of their immigration status.
### Exact Actions We Can Take
1. **Petitions**: - **Sign Petitions**: Join platforms like Change.org or MoveOn.org, which often have petitions addressing immigration reform. For instance, a petition might call for the protection of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for individuals from countries facing crises. - **Create a Petition**: If you feel strongly about a specific issue, create a petition advocating for more inclusive immigration policies. Platforms like Care2 or Petition.org can be useful.
2. **Contact Your Representatives**: - Write to your local and federal representatives expressing your views on immigration. Here’s how to do it effectively: - **Find Your Representatives**: Visit [GovTrack.us](https://www.govtrack.us) to find your senators and representatives. - **Model Email Template**: ``` Subject: Urgent Support for Fair Immigration Policies Dear [Representative's Name],
I am writing to express my concern regarding the current state of immigration policy and the recent statements made by government officials. I believe that we must prioritize humane treatment of all individuals, regardless of their immigration status.
I urge you to support policies that protect immigrant rights and promote pathways to citizenship rather than punitive measures.
Thank you for your attention to this critical issue.
Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Address] [Your Email] ```
3. **Write to Local Newspapers**: - Submit opinion pieces or letters to the editor about the importance of supporting immigrant communities. Share personal stories or data that emphasize the positive contributions of immigrants to society. Check local newspaper websites for their submission guidelines.
4. **Engage on Social Media**: - Use social media platforms to raise awareness. Share articles, personal stories, and resources that highlight the importance of immigration reform. Engage in discussions that challenge negative narratives.
5. **Support Organizations**: - Donate to or volunteer with organizations that support immigrants, such as: - **American Immigration Council**: [www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org](http://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org) - **United We Dream**: [www.unitedwedream.org](http://www.unitedwedream.org) - **National Immigration Law Center**: [www.nilc.org](http://www.nilc.org)
### Who to Write To
1. **Local Representatives**: - Contact your U.S. Senators and Representatives. For example: - Senator [Name] [Senator's Office Address] Senate Office Building Washington, DC [Zip Code] Email: [Senator’s Official Email]
2. **State Legislators**: - Reach out to your state senators and representatives, especially those who sit on immigration committees.
3. **Local Government Officials**: - Contact your mayor or city council members, advocating for local policies that support immigrant communities.
### Conclusion
By engaging in these actions, we can contribute to a culture that values human dignity and fights against the harmful narratives surrounding immigration. It’s essential to remain informed, connected, and proactive in advocating for a more inclusive society. Every action counts, and collective efforts can lead to meaningful change.